The Doctors Company studied diagnostic imaging medical malpractice claims with incidental finding mismanagement. Between 2007 and 2022, there were 51 cases, 41 percent of which involved death, and 41 percent had an indemnity payment (money paid through settlement or adjudication). This case highlights the importance of communicating concerning results to the ordering clinician and using closed-loop communication with the primary care team.
Allegation
The family alleged failure to follow up on incidental lung findings in a coronary CT angiography (CCTA) report resulted in delayed diagnosis of lung cancer.
Background
An elderly patient with a history of left carotid arteriosclerosis and long-term smoking presented to the primary care practice for an annual exam. The patient was seen by an advanced practice clinician (APC1), who noted a right-sided carotid bruit. APC1 referred the patient to an interventional cardiologist. The cardiologist ordered a CCTA of the carotid arteries. The study showed bilateral internal carotid artery stenosis. The radiologist also noted incidental findings of numerous ill-defined ground glass infiltrates and a right lung soft tissue density. The radiologist recommended follow up with a chest CT.
The radiologist discussed the CCTA findings with the PCP instead of the cardiologist who ordered the test. At the PCP office, APC2 signed the report but didn’t review it. The PCP scheduled an appointment with the patient, who saw APC1. APC1 did not review the CCTA report and was unaware of the incidental findings.
One year later, a follow-up CCTA was ordered by the cardiologist. The study showed stable carotid stenosis and progressive disease in the right lung. The PCP called the patient to discuss the findings and ordered the recommended chest CT, which revealed a new thyroid nodule and a persistent soft tissue density in the right upper lobe. A PET scan indicated widespread disease. The patient was diagnosed with late stage adenocarcinoma of the lung, underwent chemotherapy, and died within a year.
Key Contributing Factors in the Claim
Communication Deficiencies
- The CCTA report was sent to the PCP instead of the cardiologist.
- The cardiologist reviewed the report and took no action on the incidental findings, assuming that the PCP would do so.
Delayed Diagnosis
- The report was noted as read and filed without it having been read by APC2.
- The patient was never informed of the incidental findings.
Patient Safety Considerations
Manage Results
- Implement closed-loop test tracking to reduce the risk of harm related to missed information.
- Use collaborative communication with referring and consulting practitioners.
- Prioritize unexpected or critical findings with direct handoff of care to the ordering or PCP. Determine who will be responsible for informing the patient.
- Refrain from signing any results that have not been fully reviewed.
- Standardize protocols for documenting incidental findings. Consider highlighting incidental findings in imaging reports.
Improve Patient Communication
- Facilitate patient understanding when communicating health information by using plain language and asking the patient to teach-back what they have heard to confirm accuracy.
- Teach the patient how to access electronic medical records and diagnostic testing results. Empower them to follow up and ask questions.
For assistance, contact Patient Safety and Risk Management at (800) 421-2368 or patientsafety@thedoctors.com.
The guidelines suggested here are not rules, do not constitute legal advice, and do not ensure a successful outcome. The ultimate decision regarding the appropriateness of any treatment must be made by each healthcare provider considering the circumstances of the individual situation and in accordance with the laws of the jurisdiction in which the care is rendered.
J03780 11/26