Good documentation improves patient safety by providing quality information to downstream practitioners and decreasing risk for both the patient and the clinician. This case study demonstrates the value of thorough care and documentation.
In this case, the parents’ recollection of the child's pain after splinting differed from the urgent care medical record, and the documented reassessment became important when the experts reviewed the care.
Allegation
The family sued the urgent care center and the physician assistant (PA), alleging that negligent splint application led to compartment syndrome. The plaintiff also alleged that subsequent clinicians failed to diagnose the condition.
Background
After a fall, a toddler experienced pain and refused to walk. The parents took the child to a local urgent care center for evaluation where a PA assessed the child. Vital signs were stable with pain 8/10 on the FLACC pain scale on admission and 4/10 at discharge. The physical exam revealed bruising and swelling of the lower leg. The radiology exam indicated a non-displaced oblique fracture of the distal tibia.
The PA placed a long anterior and posterior splint with knee flexion, and a distal stirrup was applied. A referral to an orthopedic specialist was made and an appointment scheduled for the following day. Discharge instructions included splint maintenance and pain control.
The orthopedic specialist confirmed the diagnosis and placed a short leg cast, split all the way to the skin to allow for swelling. The patient’s skin was intact with good circulation and normal capillary refill. The parents were instructed to follow up with an orthopedic specialist in three weeks for cast removal and repeat radiology exam. The parents were also advised to go to the ED if there were changes in the toe color or temperature.
A week later, the patient was seen by the pediatrician with complaints of increased swelling and pain, fever, and vomiting. The pediatrician referred the patient to an orthopedic specialist, who saw the patient the same day. The orthopedic specialist noted swelling with good capillary refill and opined that the swelling was a result of a long car ride with the leg in a dependent position. A few days later, the patient returned to the orthopedic specialist with increased upper leg swelling. The cast was removed with evidence of what appeared to be burns at the ankle and calf. The x-ray revealed good alignment, and a short top walking boot was placed. Two days later, the patient was admitted to the hospital with a fever and pressure ulcer. The patient subsequently underwent emergency surgery for debridement and fasciotomies. The surgeon found compartment syndrome with aseptic necrosis of anterior and posterior compartments. The patient was treated with wound care and antibiotics.
The patient required ongoing physical therapy and surgical repair of an ankle plantar flexion contracture. After three years, the patient was thriving with no loss of function.
The expert witnesses agreed that the care provided by the practitioner was within the standard of care, and the court granted summary judgement in favor of the PA. However, there are patient safety learning opportunities present.
Patient Safety Considerations
Implement the following strategies to increase patient safety and limit the potential for patient harm.
Documentation Exemplars
- The parents alleged symptoms and behavior that were contrary to documentation in the record. The urgent care PA described checking the splint fit with a finger and leaving the toes exposed for observation. At the next day visit, the orthopedic specialist noted the toe down position and documented normal capillary refill.
- The parents alleged the patient’s pain increased after the splint was applied and that the child was inconsolable. The urgent care medical record documentation revealed a FLACC pain score of 8/10 at presentation and 4/10 at discharge.
- The PA documented discharge instructions and the referral that was secured before the family left the office. When arranging a referral, communicate relevant findings and treatment details to the practitioner assuming care.
Improve Communication and Rapport
The family was on vacation when the child was injured, adding additional stress to an already difficult situation.
- Establish rapport with patients by using active listening skills, repeating key points, and using teach-back to assess understanding.
- Provide an opportunity for patients and their family or supporters to ask and have their questions answered. Document the concerns raised and what was discussed in consent or refusal when applicable.
- Use patient-centered communication: Explain why it is important to do something and how it will help the condition or problem.
- Review The Doctors Company’s Effective Patient Communication Guide for more strategies.
For assistance, contact Patient Safety and Risk Management at (800) 421-2368 or patientsafety@thedoctors.com.
The guidelines suggested here are not rules, do not constitute legal advice, and do not ensure a successful outcome. The ultimate decision regarding the appropriateness of any treatment must be made by each healthcare provider considering the circumstances of the individual situation and in accordance with the laws of the jurisdiction in which the care is rendered.
J03781 11/26