A review of closed orthopedic claims indicated that clinical judgment concerns, poor communication with the patient and between practitioners, and limited documentation are common contributing factors to claims. This case highlights the importance of listening to the patient, collaborating with clinical staff members, and documenting clinical communication in the record to ensure safe patient care.
Allegation
The patient alleged negative orthopedic care and failure to timely diagnose and treat compartment syndrome.
Background
An adult patient underwent a left total knee replacement surgery performed by the orthopedic surgeon. The patient had undergone a left knee replacement by another surgeon four years prior. The patient was on several medications, including warfarin, with a goal INR of 2.5 to 3.5.
On the first postop day, the patient was seen by an orthopedic surgeon and an orthopedic advanced practice clinician (APC). Labwork was normal. The physical examination revealed soft compartments and no calf tenderness. The patient was seen later in the day by a second APC (APC2), who noted that the patient reported 10/10 pain and refused to attend afternoon PT due to pain. The planned discharge was canceled.
On postop days two and three, the patient reported left calf pain to a third APC (APC3). The patient refused to participate in PT due to pain. APC3 ordered a left upper leg ultrasound, which showed no evidence of DVT. APC3 texted the orthopedic surgeon, who disparaged the patient in a series of text messages. On postop day four, the patient was seen by APC4. The patient reported continued pain in the lower extremity and refused PT. Later that day, a nurse noted moderate edema, diminished capillary refill, and paresthesia of the left lower leg. The compression stocking was removed and the numbness diminished. Discharge was discussed, and the patient declined, stating they needed to have better pain control before going home. The nurse contacted APC4 and the joint care liaison nurse. The joint care liaison nurse examined the patient and noted moderate edema from calf to ankle with pedal pulse present. The patient reported numbness and tingling in the left great and fifth toes and could not move them due to pain. The joint care liaison contacted APC4, who spoke to the orthopedic surgeon. The surgeon advised leg elevation, ice, and to continue with discharge plans. The conversation was not documented.
The hospitalist APC (APC5) noted the patient was in pain and refused discharge. The exam noted right lower extremity with moderate edema, good pedal pulses, and “very tight calf.” Stat bloodwork indicated low hemoglobin and hematocrit. APC5 documented that a CT to rule out hematoma should be considered if the patient continued to have pain. The patient’s nurse contacted the orthopedic practice and informed APC1 that the patient was refusing discharge. APC1 notified APC4, who texted the orthopedic surgeon. The texted conversations were not documented in the medical record.
That night, the patient’s pain worsened, requiring oxycodone and IV morphine for management. By morning, the patient was moaning and reporting 10/10 pain and had increased swelling around the ankle and calf. The nurse notified the orthopedic surgeon of the continuous pain and swollen lower leg. Shortly thereafter, APC4 and the orthopedic surgeon exchanged text messages complaining about the patient and discounting the patient’s complaints of pain.
On rounds later that morning, the orthopedic surgeon diagnosed compartment syndrome and took the patient to surgery for an emergent four-compartment fasciotomy of the left leg. A large hematoma was evacuated. The surgeon found viable muscle tissue in the anterior and lateral compartments.
Two weeks later, the patient underwent a split thickness graft of the left leg. The patient was discharged to a skilled nursing facility for rehabilitation. A neurologist diagnosed permanent residual nerve damage.
Key Contributing Factors in the Claim
Communication Deficiencies
- Text communications were unprofessional, with the orthopedic surgeon disparaging the patient to a colleague.
- Indirect communication was common and led to misinformation.
- APC5 expected the patient’s nurse to tell the orthopedic surgeon about the cancelled discharge and CT scan recommendation. The nurse contacted APC1, who contacted APC4, who texted the surgeon. The message received was that the patient refused discharge.
- There was poor rapport between the surgeon and the patient.
Failure to Appreciate Relevant Signs and Symptoms
- Care coordination was poor; there were no multidisciplinary care discussions, and the patient’s concerns were not heard.
- The patient’s pain level remained consistently high throughout the stay without definitive intervention.
- There were inadequate pain assessments when the pain was out of proportion to clinical findings.
Patient Safety Considerations
Improve Communication With Patients and Between Practitioners
- Implement sound communication methods between physicians, APCs, and direct care clinicians.
- Develop rapport with patients.
- Thoroughly document all pertinent clinical information, including conversations between healthcare practitioners.
- Implement a system to capture clinically relevant text messages in the medical record.
Reduce the Risk of Delayed Diagnosis
- Utilize team-based care and empower team members to share concerns.
- Be alert for red flags. For example, multiple complaints for the same condition despite treatment may indicate an unidentified complication.
- Practice active listening.
In this case, the expert witnesses agreed the standard of care was met for diagnosing compartment syndrome. However, they were critical of patient-related communications, and the case was settled.
For assistance, contact Patient Safety and Risk Management at (800) 421-2368 or patientsafety@thedoctors.com.
The guidelines suggested here are not rules, do not constitute legal advice, and do not ensure a successful outcome. The ultimate decision regarding the appropriateness of any treatment must be made by each healthcare provider considering the circumstances of the individual situation and in accordance with the laws of the jurisdiction in which the care is rendered.
J03785 11/26