Malpractice Case Study: Compromising Statements in Text Messages Complicate Defense

Communication issues between practitioners and patients/family are one of the leading contributing factors in malpractice claims, and asynchronous communication methods such as texting can blur traditional patient-clinician boundaries. The loosening of social inhibitions in the online environment may cause people to behave differently than they would in person, a phenomenon known as online disinhibition. This case study demonstrates the crucial importance of keeping practitioner-patient communications professional.

Allegation

The patient alleged negligent laser treatment caused permanent scarring. The suit named the advanced practice clinician (APC) and the supervising physician.

Background

A young adult patient regularly visited a medical spa and was treated by the same APC at each appointment. During a laser hair removal session, the patient suffered a third-degree burn on the upper lip. Informed consent for the laser treatment was not documented in the record. Despite treatment at the medical spa, and later by specialists, the patient sustained permanent scarring.

The patient and APC communicated almost exclusively by text before and after the treatment that resulted in the injury. In response to a photograph of the burn sent by the patient, the APC texted, “I’m so sorry. That looks terrible!” and later that day, “I’ve never seen a burn that bad.”

A month later, in response to the patient’s texts about the burn not healing as expected, the APC texted: “This is all my fault. They refunded your money, right?” When the patient indicated the spa had not sent a refund, the APC offered to write a personal check to cover the amount if the patient would sign a release of liability. The patient ceased communicating with the APC after their offer. The medical spa sent a full refund. The combination of compromising text messages and lack of informed consent documentation significantly complicated the defense of this claim.

Key Contributing Factors in the Claim

Communication Deficiencies

  • The APC became friends with the patient, which changed the nature of the text
  • When the outcome of the patient’s treatment was not as expected, the APC responded to the patient as a friend, rather than a practitioner.
  • The APC admitted liability for the care provided and offered compensation.

Lack of Informed Consent

  • The APC did not document that informed consent was discussed.
  • The patient stated that the risks of burning and scarring were not disclosed.

Patient Safety Considerations

Implement the following strategies to increase patient safety and limit the potential for patient harm.

Maintain Professional Communication

  • Maintain appropriate clinician-patient boundaries and professional decorum.
  • Do not mix professional and personal issues in text messages.
  • Take a conservative approach in text messaging with patients and self-check texting disinhibition.
  • Avoid humor, sarcasm, slang, and emojis. The patient may not pick up that a comment is sarcastic. The situation may not be humorous from the patient’s point of view.
  • Consider alternatives to texting patients, such as posting messages in a portal or in an integrated office management solution.
  • Unless you are using a text messaging solution that communicates with the electronic medical record, document clinical text messages.
  • Remember that text messages are discoverable and easy to retrieve.

Use Caution With Refunds

  • Do not use text messaging to manage important communications such as responding to an unplanned event or a refund request. Obtain input from Patient Safety and Risk Management or Member Services when patients demand refunds and reimbursements following an adverse outcome or event. For additional guidance, see our article “Handling Requests for Refunds in a Healthcare Office Practice.”
  • Notify your insurer as soon as practical if a patient submits a formal written or legal demand for compensation or becomes angry, belligerent, or threatening.
  • Use care and planning when communicating unanticipated outcomes to patients and families.
  • Do not admit or imply culpability when discussing an unanticipated outcome with a patient.
  • See our Disclosure Resources for responses to questions and statements, disclosure scenarios, steps for conducting a disclosure meeting, and an adverse outcome management flowchart.

For assistance, contact Patient Safety and Risk Management at (800) 421-2368 or patientsafety@thedoctors.com. 


The guidelines suggested here are not rules, do not constitute legal advice, and do not ensure a successful outcome. The ultimate decision regarding the appropriateness of any treatment must be made by each healthcare provider considering the circumstances of the individual situation and in accordance with the laws of the jurisdiction in which the care is rendered.

J03779 11/26

Stay in the Know

Our e-newsletters feature timely articles, videos, and guides on a range of patient safety topics.

The Doctor’s Practice

Medical Icon Clipart Subscribe

The Dentist’s Advocate

Tooth Clipart Subscribe

The Practitioner

Man and Two Women Doctors Clipart Subscribe